A costly launch mistake that drove churn and how it was fixed
Adam Robinson · Jun 2024 · 2 min read
Two weeks ago we had our first MASSIVE f*ck up at RB2B. It caused 50% of active users to churn and caused lots of brand-damaging blowback. Here’s what happened (and how we fixed it):
To set the stage:
- We launched RB2B (our Person-Level Identity tool) on March 1 - My plan was to give away the leads and push to Slack for free - Then get people to pay $495 for integrations - But people could parse the Slack block with Zapier - And do whatever they want w/ the leads without paying - There was too much value in the free plan, not enough in paid - Nobody was converting
So a month ago we realized that despite having INCREDIBLE top-of-funnel and mostly positive feedback, with our current pricing, we didn’t have a business.
1. People could easily “steal” the paid plan 2. $495 was too high for small biz, pricing was broken 3. Mid-market needed a filter and Hubspot or SF integration to pay 4. Pricing was fundamentally broken
My original plan was instead of pulling value back from the free plan - which has had viral expansion - we would add value to paid, and eventually get people to give us $495.
Also I really liked the idea of giving the leads away and charging for a workflow, because selling leads and intent data as a SaaS is a high-churn category.
The more people we spoke to the more we realized that wasn’t the best plan.
Peoples’ willingness to pay was HIGH *before* they got a taste of the free plan.
Once they saw the insane value of free, willingness went to zero.
(We have an added internal issue where we are still creating our fixed-price data asset and at the moment we’re paying a high per-unit cost for data for the free users… Many of whom we believe may not be looking at the data regularly)
How did we solve these problems?
1. In mid-may, we created a “free trial” for pro, which would run out mid-June 2. People could continue with the free plan, but had to log in and click “free” 3. The free plan did not include killer features like the HubSpot integration, Hot Pages, ICP filter
This broke our internet and ruined Robb Clarke’s weekend.
Here are some stats:
1. Support requests for the week shot up from 1,571 to 2,319 2. “Script Churn” went from 7.6% to 52.4% 3. We were hurled hundreds insults over chat, email, and in LinkedIn comments
BUT…
We did manage to stop buying records for users that signed up, installed the script, and WEREN’T actively looking at them.
If you really cared about our data, you either figured out how to get it back on, or you talked to us.
And many people decided they actually wanted the paid features when the trial ran out.
TAKEAWAY
Startups are hard.
Epic fails are unavoidable, especially this early in the journey.
I hate the brand damage that comes from making a sudden change like this.
But the reality is that we don’t really have the time to roll things out properly.
And I’ve found that if your product is great, when you’re a young startup, most are forgiving.
Thank you for your patience! 🙏
Written by Adam Robinson and shared publicly; kept here in full, in his memory.