What made one cold email worth answering
Adam Robinson · Feb 2026 · 1 min read
This is the only cold email I answered in the last 12 months.
Here's why it worked on me:
1. Subj line is prob weakest point, but I opened it because I know the guy (so do many others, he is good at going viral)
2. Pattern interrupt with the “Adam! Wasn’t quite sure…”
3. Knows I’m not testing Meta ads (prob b/c my meta ads library is so tiny)
4. Very specific - yet unspecific - social proof, emphasizing companies “like me”
5. Gains more credibility through the “run this playbook enough times” setup for the CTA
6. Nice use of the money-back guarantee in the CTA.
If he’s hitting people actually doing influencer in B2B, I bet he’s doing pretty well with this email.
Am I correct Kennan????
Did I miss anything in my analysis???
Written by Adam Robinson and shared publicly; kept here in full, in his memory.